Am I getting a good deal?

The blue book says the Mazda is worth $11,405 with that mileage for that model... The Hyundai was worth $8,545 so you should try to make an offer on the Mazda instead! Now remember, at about 100,000 miles on most cars the timing belt & water pump are due. That can be very expensive: at a shop would be around $700. If you hire a mechanic maybe like $200-$300 and if you do it yourself maybe around $100. And most cars need a tune up every 30,000 miles so the tune up for the mazda will be at 90,000 which again can be very expensive at a shop. But Mazda all around is defenitly more reliable then Hyundai!